Whey Sensitivity and How to Choose a Dairy-Free Protein Powder

Key Takeaways

• For some people, whey protein can trigger digestive issues, skin problems, congestion, or glucose fluctuations, especially if there’s an intolerance or sensitivity.
• Plant-based options like pea, rice, hemp, soy, pumpkin seed, and blends can provide comparable protein, often with fewer side effects and added nutrition.
• Choosing a well-tested product, paying attention to ingredients, and using tools like Signos to track glucose and symptoms can help you find the powder that supports both digestion and metabolic health

that {{mid-cta}}

Whey protein has become almost synonymous with muscle building and post-workout recovery. You'll find it in shakes, bars, and even protein-boosted snacks. But despite its popularity, whey doesn't agree with everyone. For some people, a scoop of whey can lead to bloating, gas, congestion, or even glucose spikes rather than better performance.

‍

This guide explains what whey sensitivity looks like, how it differs from lactose intolerance and allergy, and how to choose a dairy-free protein powder that fits your body and your metabolic goals.

What Is Whey and Why It May Cause Sensitivity

Whey is one of the two main proteins in cow's milk (the other is casein). It's separated from the curds during the cheese-making process, then dried and filtered into the powders you see on store shelves.¹ Depending on the type, whey may contain varying amounts of lactose, the natural sugar in milk, along with dairy proteins.

‍

Not everyone processes those components the same way. People who don't produce enough lactase (the enzyme that breaks down lactose) have lactose intolerance and may experience gas, cramping, or diarrhea after consuming dairy products.² Many people with lactose intolerance can still consume whey protein without difficulty, especially whey protein isolate.

‍

Other people react not to the sugar but to the proteins themselves, which can lead to symptoms ranging from mild to severe. In rare cases, a true milk protein allergy is involved, which can lead to a life-threatening allergic reaction, including anaphylaxis.³

‍

Gut health can also play a role. In people with gut inflammation or microbiome imbalances, whey might contribute to more bloating, discomfort, or other symptoms. Studies also show that whey can sometimes support beneficial bacteria, which supports that responses are highly individual.⁴

Signs You Might Be Sensitive to Whey

Food allergies, sensitivities, and intolerances trigger an immune response, and some people notice right away when whey doesn't sit well with them. For others, the symptoms are more subtle and build over time. If you're wondering whether whey might be part of the problem, these signs can offer clues⁵:

‍

• digestive issues, including bloating, gas, or abdominal cramping
• loose stools or urgent trips to the bathroom
• nausea
• skin issues, including acne flare-ups, rashes, or itchy, irritated skin
• congestion, post-nasal drip, or increased mucus
• headaches or a sluggish, "run-down" feeling
• trouble with focus or energy
• glucose spikes (decreased insulin sensitivity due to acute inflammation)⁶

Benefits of Switching to Dairy-Free Protein

If you've experienced any of the above signs of whey protein sensitivity, consider changing to a dairy-free protein powder. For many people, dairy-free options feel better. Here are some other benefits you might notice from making the swap:

‍

• Gentler on digestion. Dairy-free (DF) options contain no lactose or milk proteins, so some people notice easier digestion.
• Less bloating. Since DF powders are often easier to digest, many people experience less gas, cramping, and bloating.
• May improve skin issues. If whey protein is the culprit of acne or skin rashes, choosing a non-dairy option could lead to improvements.
• More than just protein. Some plant-based powders naturally include fiber, magnesium, and iron, so you get more nutrition per scoop.

Best Types of Dairy-Free Protein Powders

There's no single "right" plant-based protein. Each one has its own strengths, and the best choice is usually the one your body tolerates and that you'll actually use. Here's a quick look at the most common options and what they bring to the table:

Pea protein

Mild in flavor and easy to blend, pea protein is one of the most popular options. A typical scoop offers roughly 20–25 grams of protein and contains plenty of essential amino acids, including leucine, which supports muscle repair.^7,8

Brown rice protein

Brown rice protein is generally well-tolerated and hypoallergenic. It provides roughly 24 grams of protein per scoop, depending on the brand.⁹ On its own, it's slightly lower in certain amino acids, which is why you'll often see it included in blends with pea protein to provide a more balanced amino acid profile.¹⁰

Hemp protein

Made from ground hemp seeds, this option naturally includes both fiber and protein. It has a slightly nutty, earthy taste, and the protein content per scoop is lower—about 15 grams per serving, making it a nice addition to smoothies rather than the sole protein source.¹¹

Soy protein

Soy is one of the few complete plant-proteins, meaning it contains all the essential amino acids. It provides roughly 20 grams of protein per scoop.¹² For most people, moderate soy intake is safe, but those with thyroid disease or taking certain antidepressants may need to limit it.¹³ Speak to a healthcare professional if you're unsure if soy protein is right for you.

Pumpkin seed protein

Pumpkin seed powders tend to be gentle on digestion and provide fiber and minerals, such as magnesium and zinc. A serving of pumpkin seed protein powder boasts 18 grams of protein.¹⁴

Protein blends

Many brands combine pea, rice, and other plant proteins to improve texture and provide a more complete amino acid profile. Most blends have a similar protein content to whey protein, offering 20-25 grams per scoop.

‍

As with most nutrition choices, the "best" one is personal. Trying a couple of options, paying attention to how you feel, and watching your glucose trends can help you land on the powder that suits you best.

What to Look For When Choosing a Dairy-Free Protein Powder

With so many protein powders on the market, it can be hard to choose the right one. A few smart shopping criteria can help you find one that supports your goals and feels good in your body.

‍

• Complete amino acid profile: Look for a powder that contains all essential amino acids, or a blend (such as pea + rice) that fills in any gaps so your muscles get what they need.
• Minimal added sugar: Excess sugar can cause unwanted glucose spikes, so choose products with little to no added sweeteners.
• Short ingredient list: If you're sensitive to gums or artificial additives, a shorter ingredient list may be easier on digestion.
• Third-party testing for purity: Independent verification (for example, NSF Certified for Sport or other reputable labs) can give confidence that what's on the label matches what's in the tub.
• Digestibility enhancers: Some powders contain enzymes or probiotics that may help reduce bloating or gas in sensitive individuals.
• Taste and texture you enjoy: A protein powder you don't mind drinking regularly is far more likely to become a sustainable habit.

Heavy Metals in Protein Powders

You may have seen recent headlines warning that some protein powders contain heavy metals such as lead, cadmium, and arsenic. That sounds scary, but these metals occur naturally in soil and water, which means plants can absorb trace amounts. When plant ingredients are concentrated into powders, those traces sometimes show up in testing, and that doesn't automatically mean the product is unsafe.

‍

A study examining a broad range of protein powders found that many products contained trace amounts of heavy metals. However, when researchers calculated how much a person would realistically consume (up to 2 or 3 scoops per day), the total exposure still fell below established safety limits for most people. Plant-based powders were more likely to contain slightly higher amounts than whey, but overall, the researchers concluded that typical use is unlikely to pose a meaningful health risk.¹⁵

‍

The safest approach is to choose brands that use third-party testing and are transparent about their sourcing. Stay within serving recommendations and focus on a varied, whole-foods diet to help lower overall exposure.

How Protein Impacts Glucose Stability

Protein does more than help muscles recover after a workout. It also helps keep glucose more stable throughout the day.

‍

When you combine protein with carbohydrates, it slows digestion and delays the release of glucose into the bloodstream, helping reduce blood sugar spikes. Protein also influences hormones that control appetite, dialing down ghrelin (the hormone that drives hunger) and increasing leptin (the hormone that signals fullness). That combination can make it easier to avoid overeating or constant grazing between meals.

‍

Over time, protein supports muscle growth and maintenance, and muscle tissue is one of the body's largest users of glucose. Generally, the more muscle you have, the better your insulin sensitivity.¹⁶

‍

While whey protein has been studied extensively in this area, many dairy-free alternatives can offer similar metabolic benefits when they're part of balanced meals or snacks, like a smoothie with plant protein, berries, spinach, and nut butter, or a bowl of oatmeal topped with pumpkin seed protein and chia seeds. The key is combining protein with fiber and healthy fats so the meal is balanced and high in complete protein.

How Signos Helps You Find the Right Protein Source

Not all protein sources affect your body the same way, even when the nutrition label looks similar. With Signos and a continuous glucose monitor (CGM), you can see how different protein shakes and powders influence your glucose across meals, workouts, and recovery, helping you identify which options keep your levels steadier.

‍

By logging protein intake alongside how you feel, Signos makes it easier to spot patterns. If you consistently notice bloating, fatigue, or congestion after a certain protein (and your glucose curve shows more variability), that combination may signal a sensitivity. In some cases, subtle glucose fluctuations can reflect underlying inflammation or physiological stress, giving you an early signal to adjust.

Signos features that support protein testing:

• Real-time glucose tracking (CGM): Observe how different protein sources affect glucose stability before and after workouts or between meals.
• Food and symptom logging: Log protein type, brand, and timing, along with digestive symptoms or energy levels, to uncover repeat patterns.
• Daily insights (Dailies): Get day-by-day feedback on how your protein choices impacted glucose variability and recovery.
• Weekly Insights report: Review longer-term trends to identify which protein sources consistently support steadier glucose and fewer symptoms.

Experiments to try with Signos:

• Protein source comparison: Test whey, plant-based, and collagen proteins on separate days while keeping timing and portion size consistent.
• Workout pairing test: Compare the same protein shake post-workout versus as a standalone snack to see how context affects glucose response.
• Ingredient sensitivity experiment: Try a clean-label protein with minimal additives, then compare it to one with sweeteners or gums to assess glucose and digestive differences.
• Timing experiment: Test protein in the morning versus later in the day to see when it best supports stable energy and recovery.

By combining real-time glucose data, daily feedback, and weekly trend analysis, Signos helps you confidently choose a protein source that supports stable glucose, better digestion, and sustained energy, without relying on guesswork or one-size-fits-all advice.

The Bottom Line

Whey sensitivity is common, and if you have it, it doesn't mean you have to sacrifice muscle recovery or metabolic health. High-quality dairy-free protein powders can provide the protein you need with fewer side effects. Choose a plant-based option that works well for you, and use Signos to track how it affects your glucose so you can fine-tune your routine.

Learn More With Signos’ Expert Advice

Learn how Signos can improve your health with expert guidance to help you interpret glucose patterns and understand how factors like protein supplements can affect your metabolic health. Explore Signos’ science-backed, expert-written blog to learn more.